Pies

Apple Pie
Choose from:
Crumb, Lattice, Full Crust or Sugar Free
Crumb, Lattice, Full Crust or Sugar Free
This was the first pie Pappy's Orchard started making and is one of our signature desserts. Using hand-peeled apples from our orchard, this pie is sure to satisfy any appetite!
Availability: Year-round
Currently displayed with: Lattice Topping

Caramel Apple Pie
Choose from:
Crumb, Lattice or Full Crust
Crumb, Lattice or Full Crust
This apple pie features our own homemade caramel. It is a very fragrant pie and is sure to please your sweet tooth - you may find it hard to eat just one piece!
Availability: Year-round
Currently displayed with: Crumb Topping

Double Apple Pie
Choose from:
Crumb, Lattice or Full Crust
Crumb, Lattice or Full Crust
The extra apple punch comes from our own boiled apple cider. This is a holiday classic and our youngest daughter Esther's favorite apple pie. It uses a mixed blend of apples, and as always our homemade pie crust.
Availability: Year-round
Currently displayed with: Crumb Topping

Eli’s Apple Pie
Choose from:
Crumb, Lattice or Full Crust
Crumb, Lattice or Full Crust
This is an award winning pie at Saucon Valley's Grower Market. Eli developed this pie with his grandmother and we are proud to replicate it and pass the deliciousness onto you!
Availability: Year-round
Currently displayed with: Crumb topping

Sour Cream Apple Pie
Choose from:
Crumb, Lattice or Full Crust
Crumb, Lattice or Full Crust
We took a traditional pie and gave it a little something extra. This delicious pie is great for any special occasion, and is made from a mixture of our orchard's apples.
Availability: Year-round
Currently displayed with: Crumb Topping

Apricot Pie
Choose from:
Crumb, Lattice or Full Crust toppings
Crumb, Lattice or Full Crust toppings
A true summer delight - this pie is a classic for our family, filled with holiday and family reunion memories of Lisa's childhood! This pie just brings a warm feeling to any meal!
Availability: Year-round.
Currently displayed with: Crumb topping

Blueberry Pie
Choose from:
Crumb, Lattice, Full Crust or Sugar Free
Crumb, Lattice, Full Crust or Sugar Free
Full of antioxidants, our pies begins with our own handpicked blueberries. Complemented with our own pie crust we bake each of our pies with love and attention to detail just like Mom did. Show those blue lips!
Availability: Year-round
Currently displayed with: Lattice Topping

Blueberry Sour Cream Pie
Choose from:
Crumb, Lattice or Full Crust toppings
Crumb, Lattice or Full Crust toppings
We enhanced our blueberry pie to delight the cream lovers! This recipe was originally provided to Lisa by one of her good friends. Our family has enjoyed it for years and we're honored to share it with you!
Availability: Year-round
Currently displayed with: Crumb Topping

Cherry Pie
Choose from:
Crumb, Lattice, Full Crust or Sugar Free
Crumb, Lattice, Full Crust or Sugar Free
A pie any president would enjoy, this delight exemplifies of truth and honor! A very beautiful pie that begs for a full-crust option. This pie is also our youngest son Eli's favorite pie and uses the classic pie cherry as the start to ensure the perfect combination of flavors.
Availability: Year-round
Currently displayed with: Full Crust

Chocolate Cream
For chocolate lovers only! This pie has a chocolate cream base topped with mounds of meringue to help make this a dessert full of antioxidants. It will be hard to eat just one slice of this dark chocolate pie!
Availability: Year-round

Coconut Cream
Even if you're one a diet, this one pie that's worth eating! With a light coconut pudding base topped with meringue, and accented with toasted coconuts, this is pie is sure to taste great!
Availability: Year-round

Coconut Custard
Choose from:
Sugar Free
Sugar Free
This pie has a coconut custard base topped with coconut, and was Pappy's favorite pie! In fact, he used request this special pie a mere hour before his noon-time lunch. Definitely a beautiful pie!
Availability: Year-round

Funny Cake
For those born without a funny bone, Funny cake is sure to make you smile. A PA Dutch classic with chocolate goo on the bottom and a cake-like top, this is one pie you can even enjoy during breakfast or dinner! Either way, topped with a little bit of chocolate syrup this is sure to cure your sadness. :-)
Availability: Year-round

Lemon Meringue Pie
Michael's absolute favorite pie, this treat always brings a smile to his face. The pronounced lemon flavor comes from freshly squeeze lemons, topped with our signature meringue.
Availability: Year-round

Lemon Sponge Pie
This old-time classic complete with bright lemon flavor is light and refreshing! This pie is perfect anytime of the year.
Availability: Year-round

Orchard Pie
Choose from:
Crumb, Lattice or Full Crust
Crumb, Lattice or Full Crust
This Seasonal pie features a peach base, accented with seasonal fruit such as blueberries, blackberries, plums, and strawberries. To show the full beauty of the pie, you'll want to choose a lattice topping!
Availability: August through October
Currently displayed with: Image not available

Peach Pie
Choose from:
Crumb, Lattice, Full Crust or Sugar Free
Crumb, Lattice, Full Crust or Sugar Free
With the taste of summer-time, these pies fly off our bakery shelves as they bring a splash of summer to any season. While available, we use peaches fresh from our orchard, switching to our orchard's frozen peaches during the cooler months.
Availability: Year-round
Currently displayed with: Lattice Topping

Pecan Pie
For the squirrel in all of us, pecans are a considered a brain food that are high in fiber. This pie reminds one of our customers of their childhood home down south years ago.
Availability: Year-round
Currently displayed with: Image not available

Peaches ‘n Cream Pie
Choose from:
Crumb, Lattice or Full Crust
Crumb, Lattice or Full Crust
This pie is sure to please anytime of the year! This recipe was inspired during a particularly heavy peach season. Made with a variety of white and yellow peaches, this treat turns any meal into a special meal worth celebrating!
Availability: Year-round
Currently displayed with: Full Crust

Pumpkin Pie
Choose from:
Regular or Sugar Free
Regular or Sugar Free
A Thanksgiving classic and tradition that is good the whole year through. Enjoy this pie as a standalone or topped with whipped cream, maple syrup, or caramel!
Availability: Year-round

Raisin Pie
Choose from:
Crumb, Lattice or Full Crust
Crumb, Lattice or Full Crust
Considered natures laxative, this pie is a traditional funeral pie, and a Pennsylvania Dutch classic often found in cookbooks from the 40s and 50s. The raisins are plumbed in water with a sprinkling of sugar and lemon rind. It is traditionally a full-crusted pie, but you can make that choice!
Availability: Year-round
Currently displayed with: Image not available

Red, White and Blue Pie
Choose from:
Crumb, Lattice, Full Crust or Sugar Free
Crumb, Lattice, Full Crust or Sugar Free
Memorial Day through Labor day this pie helps celebrate national holidays! Made with fresh strawberries, our own apples, and blueberries. This is a stunning pie will be sure to get lots of comments at your next gathering.
Availability: Year-round
Currently displayed with: Lattice

Rhubarb Pie
Choose from:
Crumb, Lattice or Full Crust
Crumb, Lattice or Full Crust
For serious rhubarb lovers this pie is an absolute must! Accented with just enough sugar to enhance the full-flavored rhubarb, this recipe has been in Michael's family for many generations.
Availability: March through May
Currently displayed with: Image not available

Shoofly Pie
Choose from:
Traditional Wet-Bottom or Cake-like bottom
Traditional Wet-Bottom or Cake-like bottom
If you're looking for a traditional Pennsylvania Dutch pie - this is the pie to taste! After much trial and error, this has become our best selling pie by far! A classic wet-bottom is the standard we bake, however for those who prefer a cake-version, feel free to place a special order!
Availability: Year-round

Strawberry Pie
Choose from:
Crumb, Lattice or Full Crust
Crumb, Lattice or Full Crust
This is a berry lover's dream and A favorite for Mother's Day. This pie is made year-round, or by request with fresh berries.
Availability: Year-round
Currently displayed with: Image not available

Fresh Strawberry Pie
This no-bake pie features mounds of fresh strawberries that are hand-sliced and covered in a decorative glaze. Our children used to spend hours looking for the biggest strawberry that would be the pie topper! It's also one of Michael's favorite pies as well.
Availability: April through September
Currently displayed with: Image not available

Strawberry Rhubarb Pie
Choose from:
Crumb, Lattice or Full Crust
Crumb, Lattice or Full Crust
A seasonal favorite offered March through May, this pie starts with our own fresh rhubarb and is complemented by strawberries. For our family, this pie exemplifies the beginning of the fruit season excitement!
Availability: March through May
Currently displayed with: Image not available

